Can Arne Slot Break This Premier League Manager ‘Curse’? | OneFootball

Can Arne Slot Break the Dutch Manager Curse in the Premier League?

The Dutch are known for their footballing prowess, producing top-tier talent and managers that have taken European clubs to great heights. However, when it comes to the Premier League, Dutch managers seem to falter. With Arne Slot poised to take the reins at Liverpool, many wonder if he can finally break the curse that has plagued his compatriots.

Dutch Track Record in England

Ruud Gullit was the Premier League’s first Dutch manager when he took over Chelsea in 1996, and while he did lead them to an FA Cup win in 1997, his tenure was short-lived. The same can be said for other Dutch managers who followed in his footsteps. Erik ten Hag may be the most successful Dutchman in England, winning both the FA Cup and Carabao Cup with Manchester United. But as The Athletic points out, Dutch managers have struggled to adapt to the Premier League’s demands.

Photo: IMAGO

One of the reasons for this, according to former Liverpool forward Ryan Babel, is the “Dutch ego.” Babel notes that Dutch coaches often refuse to adapt to new environments, believing their methods will work anywhere. “We are not going to adapt, we always try to play our way,” Babel told The Athletic, highlighting the rigid approach that has hampered many Dutch managers in England.

Arne Slot: A Different Breed?

Slot, who has found success with Feyenoord, might be the exception to the rule. He led Feyenoord to the Europa Conference League final and secured an Eredivisie title, showcasing his tactical acumen and ability to get the best out of his players. Jan Everse, one of Slot’s first managers, believes he could succeed at Liverpool, stating that Slot is a “diplomat” unlike his predecessors, who were often perceived as arrogant and stubborn.

Everse’s optimism is echoed by those who have followed Slot’s career closely. The early days of his tenure at Feyenoord were challenging, but once his ideas began to take hold, the team flourished. Slot’s adaptability and communication skills could be what sets him apart from the likes of Gullit, Koeman, and De Boer, who all struggled with player relations and, ultimately, failed to meet expectations.

Challenges Ahead for Slot

Despite the optimism surrounding Slot, the Premier League is a different beast altogether. It’s a league where the pace is relentless, and every match feels like a final. Slot will need to adapt quickly, or he risks becoming another Dutchman who couldn’t quite make the jump.

Gullit’s downfall at Chelsea, as detailed by Michael Duberry in an interview with JOE, stemmed from a shift in personality. Duberry described Gullit the player as “approachable” but noted that as a manager, he became “distant” and referred to his players as “lovely boy” in a condescending manner. Such disconnects can be fatal in the Premier League, where man-management is as crucial as tactical nous.

Frank de Boer’s short-lived tenure at Crystal Palace is a stark reminder of how quickly things can unravel in England. De Boer tried to implement a more attractive style of play but failed to adapt to the squad at his disposal. As Babel pointed out, the Premier League won’t adapt to foreign coaches; they must adapt to it.

Can Slot Defy History?

Arne Slot’s success at Feyenoord offers hope that he might be able to break the Dutch managerial curse in the Premier League. His record suggests he can inspire teams to punch above their weight, but as The Athletic reminds us, “the step from the Dutch Eredivisie to the Premier League is simply very big.” Slot will need to be both patient and adaptable if he’s to succeed where others have failed.

The clock will start ticking the moment he steps into Anfield. Liverpool fans will expect results quickly, and while his diplomatic approach might buy him some time, he will need to deliver on the pitch to avoid becoming another footnote in the history of Dutch managers in England.

Our View – Anfield Index Analysis

As Liverpool fans, we’re no strangers to the hype that comes with new managerial appointments. Slot’s reputation precedes him, and his success at Feyenoord has us buzzing with anticipation. His ability to turn Feyenoord around, taking them from mid-table mediocrity to title contenders, is exactly what we need at Anfield.

Yes, the Premier League is a different challenge, but Slot seems to be the type of manager who thrives under pressure. His tactical flexibility and willingness to adapt are qualities that have been sorely missed at Liverpool in recent years. We’ve seen managers come in with a rigid philosophy and struggle to adapt to the demands of English football. Slot, however, feels different. He’s pragmatic, willing to tweak his system to suit the players at his disposal, and that could be the key to his success.

Moreover, his man-management skills, as highlighted by Everse, suggest he’s someone who can get the best out of our squad. The connection between manager and players is crucial, and if Slot can build strong relationships, we might just see him succeed where other Dutch managers have failed. It’s early days, but the signs are promising, and we’re ready to back him all the way.