Independent 2024/25 season ratings on all Newcastle United players – On the money? | OneFootball

There were 24 Newcastle United players who featured in Premier League matches in 2024/25.

So who were your winners and losers, which Newcastle United players did you rate, or not?

Always interesting to get an outside perspective and these season ratings for all 24 Newcastle United players (to feature in PL matches) come from WhoScored.

The whoscored ratings use data from every single Premier League match, over 200 raw statistics included in the automated calculation of a player’s rating, weighted according to their influence within the game.

Every event of importance is taken into account, with a positive or negative effect on ratings weighted in relation to its area on the pitch and its outcome.

Now whoscored have published season ratings for all Newcastle United players in Premier League matches in the 2024/25 season (number of PL starts and then in brackets number of sub appearances), from top to bottom…:

7.30 Alexander Isak 34 (0)

7.01 Jacob Murphy 31 (4)

6.98 Bruno Guimaraes 38 (0)

6.93 Joelinton 28 (0)

6.85 Martin Dubravka 10 (0)

6.84 Anthony Gordon 28 (6)

6.84 Dan Burn 37 (0)

6.83 Sandro Tonali 28 (8)

6.80 Nick Pope 28 (0)

6.79 Fabian Schar 33 (1)

6.77 Sven Botman 6 (2)

6.72 Harvey Barnes 17 (16)

6.70 Kieran Trippier 14 (11)

6.68 Tino Livramento 32 (5)

6.26 Lloyd Kelly 4 (6)

6.25 Joe Willock 11 (21)

6.25 Sean Longstaff 8 (17)

6.24 Lewis Miley 1 (13)

6.19 Emil Krafth 2 (10)

6.18 Matt Targett 0 (2)

6.15 Will Osula 0 (14)

6.12 Miguel Almiron 1 (8)

5.96 Callum Wilson 2 (16)

With automated ratings (or indeed other people’s!) it is always possible to have inconsistencies, but over the course of a full season, do you agree with all of the above?