Goldbridge: ‘Onana at fault, Amorim should never have picked him’ – Man United’s Embarrassing Cup Exit | OneFootball

Onana Blamed as Man Utd Suffer Defeat to Grimsby

Goldbridge Calls Out Goalkeeping Errors

Manchester United’s shock defeat to Grimsby in the Carabao Cup penalties has sparked fierce debate, with Andre Onana singled out for criticism on The United Stand Xtra Podcast. Mark Goldbridge delivered scathing player ratings, describing both goals conceded as “goals that should have been saved”.

Goldbridge’s frustration with United’s number one was clear, giving him a rating of “a one for our number one” before bluntly adding, “manager three, yeah, just for picking Onana.” The comments captured the discontent among fans after United’s elimination at the hands of lower-league opposition.

Photo IMAGO

Player Ratings Reflect Chaotic Night

Goldbridge described the penalties as “an embarrassment” and highlighted a string of underwhelming displays. He spared young Fredricson heavy criticism, rating him “a five”, saying, “he’s a young player and he really struggled… I’m not here to burn him or anything like that.” Harry Maguire received the highest rating of “six” and was named “probably our man of the match”.

Amad’s performance drew sharp remarks, with Goldbridge saying, “he can be as bad as Garnacho at times… tonight it was bad and selfish.” Sesko’s struggles were also noted as he quipped, “welcome to the Graveyard Club,” adding that it was “poor” and rating him “a four”.

Photo IMAGO

Substitutions Bring Positives

Despite the loss, Goldbridge highlighted some bright sparks from substitutes. Mason Mount, Bruno Fernandes, and Joshua Zirkzee all received “5.5” ratings, with Goldbridge admitting, “we do miss him [Bruno] even though I don’t like him in the midfield.” Mbeumo’s goal was also praised as “really good” and he was named his man of the match.

Photo IMAGO

Goldbridge summed up the team performance by assigning the manager a “three”, expressing dismay at tactical decisions and squad selection. The episode underlined growing frustrations with United’s consistency and the pressure now mounting on both the squad and Ruben Amorim’s leadership.

Photo IMAGO

Growing Fan Frustration

The podcast conversation reflected a growing fan sentiment around Onana’s form and the overall team trajectory. Goldbridge’s critique framed the result as part of a broader malaise, stating bluntly that several signings have “just lost” their edge and described the team as “a midfield that’s getting run through.” The panel’s tone resonated with United supporters calling for accountability as their cup hopes ended in disappointment.

Our View – EPL Index Analysis

For Manchester United fans, the comments from The United Stand Xtra Podcast reflect a harsh reality check. Onana’s struggles have been a point of debate since his arrival, but being labelled a “one for our number one” and blamed for the defeat to Grimsby lays bare the growing impatience. Supporters expected a commanding presence between the posts and results like this intensify calls for change.

Goldbridge’s dissection of the squad also echoes frustrations about recruitment and development. Players like Sesko and Amad, who were tipped to be impact figures, are now facing criticism for wasteful performances. Even the praise for Maguire highlights how far expectations have shifted, with the centre-back emerging as a standout in a turbulent night.

Fans will note the difference substitutes made, with Mount and Fernandes influencing the game, further demonstrating that United’s depth remains inconsistent. The podcast discussion serves as a reflection of the wider supporter base: passionate, critical, and demanding better standards from a club built on success. With cup exits and defensive woes piling up, focus will inevitably return to Onana’s ability to handle the scrutiny that comes with being United’s number one.