Celtic’s recruitment woes leaves Rodgers thinking outside the box

In partnership with

The Celtic Star

·2 Agustus 2025

Celtic’s recruitment woes leaves Rodgers thinking outside the box

As Celtic prepare to unfurl the League Flag this Sunday and celebrate last season’s Premiership triumph, the focus quickly shifts from ceremony to substance…

Celtic FC coach Brendan Rodgers looks on before the Como Cup match between Al-Ahli and Celtic FC at Giuseppe Sinigaglia Stadium on July 26, 2025 in Como, Italy. (Photo by Marco Luzzani/Getty Images)

With St Mirren the first visitors to Celtic Park this campaign, Brendan Rodgers must now decide on the starting eleven that will begin the club’s title defence.

Video OneFootball

The goalkeeping department appears straightforward

The goalkeeping department appears straightforward, with Kasper Schmeichel expected to claim the gloves, while Viljami Sinisalo provides backup from the bench but is now pushing our veteran ‘keeper hard for his place, which is just what we want across all positions. But from there, things get more complicated—particularly in defence and out wide.

Celtic player Kieran Tierney is embraced by manager Brendan Rodgers before coming on as a substitute during the pre-season friendly match between Celtic and Newcastle United at Celtic Park on July 19, 2025 in Glasgow, Scotland. (Photo by Stu Forster/Getty Images)

At left back a competitive return for Kieran Tierney would be both a popular and logical choice. His experience and attacking intent make him a natural fit for Rodgers’ system, despite the encouraging form of Japanese recruit Hayato Inamura during pre-season.

The right back slot is less clear. Tony Ralston and Colby Donovan have both had minutes over the summer, but with Alistair Johnston only recently returning from extended international duty with Canada, Rodgers may have a decision to make between easing the full-back in or trusting one of the pre-season regulars.

Who plays alongside CCV in central defence? Probably Trusty

In central defence, Cameron Carter-Vickers would usually be a guaranteed starter, but his post-surgery recovery may not yet be complete. That may open up a route for a start for Dane Murray who has really caught the eye with some assured performances in pre-season and who seems to have developed a great deal physically.

That leaves a potential partnership of Murray or Carter-Vickers with Liam Scales or Auston Trusty—neither of whom firmly claimed the position during last season, but Trusty may have edged it based on pre-season performances. Selection across the defence may come down to match sharpness rather than long-term hierarchy.

Callum McGregor with the Adidas Trophy after Celtic defeat Newcastle United 4-0 during the pre-season friendly match between Celtic and Newcastle United at Celtic Park on July 19, 2025. (Photo by Ian MacNicol/Getty Images)

A possible surprise in midfield due to the lack of wingers

The midfield battle appears more stable. Captain Callum McGregor and the ever-reliable Reo Hatate will almost certainly feature, but the third midfield slot remains open.

Benjamin Nygren and Arne Engels are the main contenders, each bringing different attributes to the table. Nygren’s versatility may give him the edge—especially if Rodgers opts for a more fluid attacking setup – but is there is a chance both could play?

And that’s because the biggest unknown lies in the attacking third, where Celtic’s lack of depth in the wide positions is becoming a real talking point.

Marco Tilio of Celtic Sporting Lisbon v Celtic, Pre Season Friendly, Football, Estadio Algarve, Portugal – 16 July 2025 Estadio Algarve Portugal Photo Carlos Rodrigues – Shutterstock

With Marco Tilio surely out of the picture, bar the possibility of a place on the bench, that leaves James Forrest and Yang as the natural wingers—both of whom have impressed enough in pre-season, but enough to demand a starting role?

Could Nygren start on the right and Daizen Maeda on the left?

This opens the door to a potential tactical shift. Could Nygren start on the right and Daizen Maeda on the left, with both tucking slightly infield to allow Tierney and (if fit) Johnston to provide width from full-back? That configuration would permit Engels to partner Hatate and McGregor in midfield and allow Forrest and Yang to be used later in the game, perhaps as impact substitutes.

COMO, ITALY – JULY 26: Shin Yamada of Celtic FC scores his goal from the penalty spot during the Como Cup match between Al-Ahli and Celtic FC at Giuseppe Sinigaglia Stadium on July 26, 2025 in Como, Italy. (Photo by Marco Luzzani/Getty Images)

Up front, new signing Shin Yamada may be in contention for a start. His pressing ability and physical presence could allow Maeda and Nygren to play closer to him in support, offering a more compact, interchangeable front three.

Como, Italy, 24th July 2025. Adam Idah of Celtic reacts during the Ajax vs Celtic Pre Season Friendly match at Stadio Giuseppe Sinigaglia, Como. Photo: Jonathan Moscrop / Sportimage

That said, Adam Idah’s familiarity with Rodgers’ system might still be preferred in the opener—particularly if the manager opts for a more conservative setup after an uncertain summer window, or if the manager having utilised Idah as a rotational option behind Kyogo and then Maeda last season, would be worried about the impact on Idah’s confidence going forward if he chose to utilise the Irishman behind a third Japanese striker this season.

Yamada arrives fit from playing in the J-League season

The other advantage to Yamada playing would be he arrives fit from the J-League season. However the other consideration is whether he arrives confident after a goalscoring drought prior to his move from Kawasaki Frontale.

Brendan Rodgers manager of Celtic meets fans before the game Cork City v Celtic, Pre Season Friendly, Football, SuperValu Pairc Ui Chaoimh, Cork, Ireland – 0 Jul 2025Cork SuperValu Pairc Ui Chaoimh Ireland Photo Lorraine O’Sullivan Shutterstock

Temptation to stick with the tried-and-tested is understandable

Rodgers then faces a choice between risk and reliability. The temptation to stick with the tried-and-tested from pre-season is understandable, especially on a high-profile day in front of a packed Celtic Park. But with concerns over creativity in the final third and a lack of clarity in the wide areas, Sunday might present the perfect opportunity for a bold tactical statement.

Whatever the decision, the first whistle of the new season brings more than just celebration—it marks the beginning of what promises to be a fascinating campaign, where every selection will be scrutinised, and every point will count.

It’s just a shame Celtic’s attacking recruitment already leaves Brendan Rodgers having to perhaps think outside the box.

Niall J

So why have one brilliant David Potter book when you can enjoy two?

Celtic in the Eighties by David Potter. Foreword by Danny McGrain. Published on Celtic Star Books on 5 September 2025. Click on image to pre-order.

Help raise funds for Celtic Youth Academy by playing the Celtic Pools Weekly Lottery and you could win up to £25,000. The lottery is £1 per week. Click on image to join.