Slot vs Ten Hag: A Tale of Two Projects as Liverpool Face United | OneFootball

Manchester United vs Liverpool: Contrasting Trajectories Under Slot and Ten Hag

It’s often said that form goes out the window when Manchester United and Liverpool clash. This sentiment rings true for one of football’s most storied rivalries, where past performances are quickly forgotten in the heat of battle. As these two giants prepare to meet once again, the focus shifts not only to the immediate outcome but also to the broader narratives surrounding the two clubs and their respective managers.

Photo: IMAGO

United’s Inconsistencies Under Ten Hag

Heading into this encounter, Manchester United find themselves in a somewhat precarious position. Despite being three years into Erik ten Hag’s tenure, the team still appears unsettled and inconsistent. Last season, United’s form was erratic, and this campaign has started in much the same way. A narrow 1-0 victory over Fulham, secured by a late goal from new signing Joshua Zirkzee, was followed by a disappointing 2-1 loss to Brighton.

The defeat at the Amex Stadium was a stark reminder of United’s ongoing struggles to dominate games. Brighton, a team known for their tactical discipline, carved out numerous chances, amassing an expected goals (xG) total of 2.09. It’s a statistic that highlights United’s vulnerabilities and raises questions about their readiness to challenge the league’s elite consistently.

Despite significant investment in the squad, United still rely heavily on counter-attacking football, a style that can yield results against stronger teams but often falls short against those they are expected to beat. Ten Hag’s arrival from Ajax was supposed to herald a new era of dominance for United, but the reality has been far more complex. The Dutchman’s tenure has been characterised by tactical adjustments and inconsistent performances, leaving the team struggling to impose their supposed quality on the opposition.

Slot’s Immediate Impact at Liverpool

In stark contrast, Arne Slot’s brief time at Liverpool has already begun to show significant promise. While it’s true that the season is only two games old, the difference in approach and execution under Slot is palpable. Liverpool, a team that looked disjointed and chaotic at times last season, now appears controlled, methodical, and highly efficient.

Last season, Liverpool’s possession-based game often lacked penetration. Despite averaging 62% possession, their play was frequently sterile, with the opposition dictating the tempo and space. The Reds found themselves chasing games far too often, conceding early goals and struggling to regain control. It was a period marked by frustration and missed opportunities.

However, under Slot, Liverpool’s approach has evolved. The team now dominates not just possession but also space and game state. They have been notably stingy in defence, allowing opponents only 0.8 xG over two games while generating a league-high 5.3 xG themselves. It’s a statistic that reflects a newfound balance between attack and defence, something that was sorely lacking last season.

The contrast between the two managers is stark. Slot, despite being in his early days at Liverpool, has already implemented a clear identity. His side controls games from start to finish, wearing down opponents and capitalising on their fatigue in the later stages of matches. This was evident in Liverpool’s recent 2-0 victory over Brentford, a game where the Reds completed an impressive 92% of their passes, their highest passing accuracy in a Premier League game on record.

Key Players Thriving Under Slot

Liverpool’s resurgence under Slot has been bolstered by the form of key players such as Mohamed Salah, Diogo Jota, Luis Diaz, and Trent Alexander-Arnold. These players, who struggled to consistently influence games last season, are now thriving in a system that plays to their strengths. The Reds have recorded 92 touches in the opposition box across their first two games, compared to just 50 for United.

This ability to control the tempo and space has resulted in Liverpool creating 10 big chances, while United have managed only six. Moreover, Ten Hag’s side has conceded chances worth 2.5 xG, further highlighting their defensive frailties.

A Critical Test at Old Trafford

As these two historic rivals prepare to meet at Old Trafford, the match will serve as a litmus test for both managers. Ten Hag, despite his experience, continues to treat games against Liverpool as one-off events, often relying on counter-attacks and individual moments of brilliance to secure results. In contrast, Slot’s Liverpool appears to be a team built on a clear and coherent strategy, one that seeks to control every aspect of the game.

If Liverpool can impose their style and limit United’s counter-attacking opportunities, Ten Hag could face just his second loss against the Merseyside club. For United, the challenge will be to disrupt Liverpool’s rhythm and exploit any weaknesses in a team that is still in the early stages of Slot’s tenure.

This match, as always, will be fiercely contested, but it’s the contrasting philosophies of the two managers that could ultimately decide the outcome. As Liverpool continue to evolve under Slot, and United search for consistency under Ten Hag, this latest chapter in their rivalry promises to be as intriguing as ever.