Serie A 2024-25 Winners and losers: All clubs rated | OneFootball

It proved to be an epic year for Italian football with drama, controversy and excitement at every turn. Giancarlo Rinaldi gives out the grades for all 20 teams in the top division this term.

Say what you like about Serie A, it was not to be outdone for dramatic finishes this season. The Scudetto, European places and relegation matters all went down to the last day. We can sit here and argue about the overall strength of the league forever but what is not in doubt is its ability to deliver some gripping entertainment.

Where there are winners, though, there have to be losers. It is alway hard to assess how successful a team’s efforts have been – especially as it has to be seen in the context of expectation at a particular club. But what follows is an attempt to grade each outfit’s campaign while taking into consideration what they might realistically have hoped to achieve.

Napoli – 9/10 Everyone knew they underperformed last season, but few expected them to bounce back in such style. The Antonio Conte effect and inspired performances from Scott McTominay and Romelu Lukaku meant they emerged as Inter’s only credible contender in the title fight. No European football helped, but they kept up their intensity impressively nonetheless, and ultimately delivered a fourth league crown which was celebrated in style and thoroughly deserved.

Inter – 7.5/10 The vote could go higher if they manage to clinch the Champions League but overall, it was still a good campaign from the strongest squad in Italy. There were a few slip-ups – notably in the Coppa Italia – but they maintained a high level of performance which surely earns Simone Inzaghi a right to be mentioned in European coaching’s elite. They will be annoyed to have missed out on another title but their continental exploits have provided plenty of compensation.

Atalanta – 8/10 If it is the end of the road for Gian Piero Gasperini, what a way to sign off. Another Champions League qualification comfortably achieved and outstanding campaigns from Mateo Retegui and Ademola Lookman among others. Yes, there were a few stumbles and grumbles along the way but, for a team which once hovered between Serie A and Serie B this is a golden age.

Juventus – 6/10 It was meant to be the start of a new era under Thiago Motta with both entertaining and winning football but he struggled to deliver either. In the end, he was shown the door and the rebuilding project started once again. Whoever gets the job needs to be given long-term security to start putting La Vecchia Signora back where she belongs. Their transfer strategy of regularly selling off quality young players needs some serious re-examination.

NAPLES, ITALY – MAY 23: Giovanni Di Lorenzo of Napoli lifts the Serie A TIM Scudetto title trophy after his team’s victory in the Serie A match between Napoli and Cagliari at Stadio Diego Armando Maradona on May 23, 2025 in Naples, Italy. (Photo by Francesco Pecoraro/Getty Images)

Roma – 7/10 If it was on the second half of the season alone then the mark would be just about a perfect 10. However, the period before Claudio Ranieri’s arrival was abysmal for a side with the quality of players the Giallorossi possessed. He steadied the ship and then set them flying high on a truly outstanding run of results. Whoever comes in will have a hard act to follow and there was not a dry eye in the house as he said goodbye to the Olimpico crowd.

Fiorentina – 6.5/10 It was another year of what might have been for the Viola as they strung together a great winning run and then a very drab streak of results. They missed out on a third Conference League final but somehow or another managed to seal a return to that competition on the final day. Moise Kean and David de Gea were highlights of an often frustrating side which may well be dismantled again in the summer.

epa12135665 Roma coach Claudio Ranieri celebrates with players the victory at the end of the Italian soccer Serie A match between Torino FC vs AS Roma at the Olimpico Grande Torino Stadium in Turin, Italy, 25 May 2025. EPA-EFE/ALESSANDRO DI MARCO

Lazio – 6/10 A bit of mixed bag with some great results but there will be regrets that such promise failed to deliver Europe of any flavour. Marco Baroni looked happy at the helm of a bigger side for the first time but it remains to be seen how happy they are with him. If nothing else, they played a part in deciding where the title ended up with their draw with Inter late in the season.

Milan – 5/10 Yes, there was the Supercoppa but this was not a season at the levels the Rossoneri are used to competing at. There was the odd sign of life but overall it never hit the heights that the club would have hoped either under the puzzling Paulo Fonseca or his countryman Sergio Conceicao. Their big players did not deliver consistently either and the fans were understandably disgruntled at the overall outcome of this campaign.

Bologna – 8/10 They might have been bumped out of the Champions League and fallen down the league table but a Coppa Italia win showed that Vincenzo Italiano was on the right track. Despite losing their coach and players like Joshua Zirkzee and Riccardo Calafiori they still fought at the top end of the table and delivered a trophy after a lengthy drought. The trick will be to build on that success.

ROME, ITALY – MAY 14: Luka Jovic, Francesco Camarda, Santiago Gimenez, Matteo Gabbia and Strahinja Pavlovic of AC Milan look dejected after the team’s defeat in the Coppa Italia Final match between AC Milan and Bologna at Stadio Olimpico on May 14, 2025 in Rome, Italy. (Photo by Paolo Bruno/Getty Images)

Como – 7/10 Another team like Roma who would be even higher if judged on the second half of the season alone. A spending splurge in January delivered an impressive upturn in form that saw them soar up the table. Cesc Fabregas has a lot of suitors and it is hardly surprising considering what he has delivered here. The club looks like it could become a Serie A reality for some time to come.

Torino – 6/10 A very vanilla season that fans of the Granata will have got used to by now. Paolo Vanoli showed signs of getting his team to produce a little more entertaining football but they never really kicked on. Che Adams proved a surprising source of goals, though, as the Scotsmen in Serie A continued to thrive. Still, a great club struggling for a real identity and the ability to trouble the top half of the table.

Udinese – 6.5/10 Another year of comfortable survival with some good performances along the way. Kosta Runjaic proved a pretty capable performer and his team did a decent job without ever truly setting the heather alight. Maybe rumours of new American owners can help them to take another step forward and try to challenge for Europe once again.

COMO, ITALY – MAY 10: Como 1907 coach Cesc Fabregas looks on before the Serie A match between Como 1907 and Cagliari Calcio at Stadio G. Sinigaglia on May 10, 2025 in Como, Italy. (Photo by Marco Luzzani/Getty Images)

Genoa – 6/10 It wasn’t spectacular but they secured their continued presence in Serie A with some comfort which did not look a certainty early on. A switch from Alberto Gilardino to Patrick Vieira at the helm was enough to ensure survival although a gamble on Mario Balotelli certainly proved to be pretty ineffective.

Verona – 6.5/10 In the 40th anniversary of their famous Scudetto win, it was enough just to keep their heads above water. They were never in serious danger of going down and that in itself is impressive. Dreams of another league title do seem an awful long way off but they did well enough after losing their influential coach Baroni in the summer.

Cagliari – 6.5/10 Did just enough to survive without ever really producing anything spectacular. In the end, they managed to find a way to win some key clashes but they will hope to do a little bit better in the seasons ahead. Still, Davide Nicola underlined his reputation as the man to turn to if you want to stay afloat.

Parma – 6/10 They started off decently but it proved to be a bit of a slog to avoid dropping back into Serie B. Capable of some exciting football but they were unable to produce the kind of consistency that might have seen them finish a bit higher up the table. Pass marks, probably, but not much more.

Lecce 6.5/10 It looked like a forlorn task at times but a heroic performance on the final day saw them home. To grab a win in Rome over Lazio in order to survive was something very much out of the ordinary and no more than some of the most passionate fans in the top division deserved.

EMPOLI, ITALY – MAY 25: Suat Serdar of Hellas Verona FC celebrates after scoring a goal during the Serie A match between Empoli and Verona at Stadio Carlo Castellani on May 25, 2025 in Empoli, Italy. (Photo by Gabriele Maltinti/Getty Images)

Empoli 5.5/10 There was a time when they looked like they could really be a surprise package but their slump was pretty brutal and their descent was rapid. Their efforts to give young Italian talents were to be admired but it was not enough to keep them above water. Still, they found some more interesting prospects for us all to admire.

Venezia 6/10 It was a bit of a miracle that they actually managed to get to the final day of the season with a shot at staying up. Selling off your star striker and talisman in January was a curious way to do business but it almost worked and Eusebio Di Francesco deserves some credit for giving most of their opponents a pretty tough test.

Monza – 3/10 Having been a bit of a revelation in the past two years, reality bit after losing some key players and their manager in the summer. Nothing seemed to spark a revival and a miserable season ended in relegation with a few rounds of the season left to play. It will be a slog to bounce back after one of the most miserable Serie A campaigns on record.