Max Eberl Explains Why Bayern Sold Matthijs de Ligt to Manchester United | OneFootball

Matthijs de Ligt’s Departure: A Divisive Decision at Bayern

The recent sale of Matthijs de Ligt to Manchester United for £42 million has sparked mixed emotions within the football world, especially among Bayern Munich fans. A popular figure at the Allianz Arena, the Dutch defender’s departure has led to heated debates, with many questioning Bayern’s decision-making process, even as the club stand firmly behind it, reveal The Mirror.

Max Eberl, Bayern’s sporting director, defended the move, asserting that the decision was based on tactical considerations rather than financial necessity. “We felt more comfortable with Upamecano and Kim because they can defend higher up the pitch. And then an offer came in for de Ligt,” Eberl explained, adding that the club saw this as an opportunity to strengthen its current defensive setup.

Photo: IMAGO

Supporter Backlash and Fan Petitions

De Ligt’s status at Bayern was not one that supporters were willing to let go of lightly. Upon learning of his potential departure, a section of fans initiated a petition to retain the defender, urging the club to reconsider. The petition highlighted the 24-year-old’s leadership and world-class defensive qualities, a testament to his reputation among the fan base.

“We all want Matthijs de Ligt to stay at FC Bayern Munich,” the petition stated. “He has proven that he’s a world-class defender, probably the best in our squad.” Despite the passionate plea, Bayern’s hierarchy stood by their decision, with Eberl noting the club’s preference for other options, like Dayot Upamecano and Kim Min-jae, who have both proven adept at high-press defending.

Erik Ten Hag’s Conundrum

From Manchester United’s perspective, Erik ten Hag will have his own set of challenges. While de Ligt’s arrival is seen as a massive coup, with fans expecting a formidable partnership between him and Lisandro Martinez, concerns remain regarding his ability to adapt to United’s high-pressing system. Eberl’s comments pointed to this potential weakness in de Ligt’s game, “He struggled to defend high up the pitch,” raising questions over whether Ten Hag’s system will expose similar vulnerabilities.

However, the Dutchman has already made a positive impact, scoring his first goal in United’s 3-0 win against Southampton after a tough Premier League debut against Liverpool. Time will tell if de Ligt can silence the doubters and become a key figure for United, or if Bayern made the right call.

Bayern Munich’s Tactical Vision

For Bayern Munich, the decision was as much about looking forward as it was about addressing current needs. Max Eberl insisted that de Ligt, despite his qualities, did not fit the tactical framework Julian Nagelsmann sought to employ with defenders capable of pressing higher up the pitch. The addition of Kim Min-jae and the continued development of Upamecano reflect the club’s long-term vision.

Still, the emotional connection between de Ligt and the Bayern faithful cannot be overlooked. His departure stings for many fans, who felt he embodied the future of Bayern’s defensive line.

Our View – EPL Index Analysis

Excited Manchester United fans will view Matthijs de Ligt’s signing as a signal of intent from the club. This is a defender who has thrived in multiple top European leagues and brings much-needed leadership and experience to a defensive line that has sometimes lacked consistency. His partnership with Lisandro Martinez, a key figure under Erik ten Hag, offers the promise of a solid and formidable backline that could lead United back to Premier League glory.

However, some concerned Bayern Munich supporters might feel that their club has let go of a generational talent. Eberl’s insistence that de Ligt didn’t fit into Bayern’s pressing tactics will hardly soothe those fans, many of whom still believe de Ligt was the best defender in their squad. Selling him to a direct European rival could backfire should de Ligt hit his stride at Old Trafford.

On balance, both clubs made their decision based on their tactical needs and long-term plans. While Bayern Munich will hope that Upamecano and Kim Min-jae form a robust defensive duo, Manchester United are betting on de Ligt’s ability to adapt to the rigours of the Premier League. In the end, only time will tell which club has made the more astute choice.