John Herdman’s Departure Leaves Toronto FC at a Crossroads | OneFootball

Following John Herdman’s exit from Toronto FC, many fans and players have reflected on his tenure, acknowledging both the progress made and the potential left unrealized. Herdman’s efforts helped Toronto FC recover from the disastrous 2022 and 2023 seasons, with 2024 offering a glimmer of hope despite its setbacks.

Keith Pelley, CEO of Maple Leaf Sports & Entertainment, expressed his gratitude for Herdman’s dedication and praised the strides made under his leadership. Pelley highlighted Herdman’s role in consolidating key players like Deybi Flores, who emerged as one of Toronto FC’s standout midfielders and remains a vital part of the team’s future plans.

Inconsistent Results and Missed Opportunities

While Herdman’s contributions were significant, Toronto FC often seemed capable of more. Questions lingered about the team’s tactical approach and physical preparedness, which at times led to disappointing results. Matches that could have turned in Toronto’s favor frequently ended in narrow losses or controversial outcomes, frustrating fans eager for sustained success.

A Rebuild for 2025

Toronto FC’s leadership, led by Pelley, has assured fans that the club is already working to secure a new head coach and chart a course for a comprehensive rebuild. This includes forming a new sporting identity and fostering a more competitive team for the 2025 MLS season.

Toronto FC’s rebuild aims to address deeper structural issues that have plagued the club in recent years. Beyond finding a new head coach, the organization is focused on enhancing player development, improving recruitment strategies, and fostering a more cohesive playing style.

This approach seeks not only to achieve short-term goals, such as playoff qualification, but also to establish a sustainable model that can deliver consistent success in the MLS and other competitions. Fans are optimistic that these efforts will restore pride and competitivene