Henry Winter: Did Slot’s Tactics Contribute to Liverpool’s Setback? | OneFootball

Liverpool’s Setback Under Slot: A Temporary Blip or Deeper Problems?

Liverpool’s shocking home defeat to Nottingham Forest has sparked intense discussion among fans and pundits alike. With Arne Slot at the helm following Jurgen Klopp’s departure in May 2024, questions have arisen about whether Slot’s tactical approach is sufficient to maintain the high standards set by the club. The latest TalkSport podcast, hosted by Marcus Buckland and featuring renowned football journalist Henry Winter, delved into Liverpool’s struggles and the broader implications of the loss.

Slot’s Tactical Choices Criticized

During the podcast, both Buckland and Winter scrutinized Arne Slot’s tactical decisions, particularly in the wake of Liverpool’s disappointing performance. Henry Winter didn’t mince words, stating, “Slot himself said it’s not good enough.” Just weeks ago, Slot was being celebrated for his brilliant management in Liverpool’s win over Manchester United, but football’s unpredictable nature quickly turned the praise into criticism. As Winter remarked, “Two weeks is a very long time in professional football.”

Winter also pointed out that Liverpool’s lack of possession was particularly surprising: “Liverpool didn’t keep the ball well enough, which is unlike them,” he said. The discussion highlighted how far Liverpool had strayed from the cohesive, possession-based football they are known for.

Both contributors agreed that Slot needs time to adapt fully to the Premier League, with Winter warning, “Every game is a potential ambush,” particularly when playing against sides that are tactically disciplined, as Nottingham Forest proved to be.

Klopp’s Departure Still Looms Large

Since Klopp’s departure in May, Slot has faced the challenge of stepping into one of the most significant managerial roles in football. Marcus Buckland noted how Klopp’s influence remains strong at Anfield, but Winter was quick to focus on the present, stating, “Slot has inherited a fantastic squad, but maybe he hasn’t been given sufficient reinforcements.”

The conversation then turned to the summer transfer window, with both pundits suggesting that Liverpool’s lack of signings could be a factor in their inconsistency. Buckland emphasized, “New manager comes in, tends to like new signings,” indicating that Slot may not have had the opportunity to fully shape the squad in his image.

Winter added that Liverpool must prioritize securing the futures of key players such as Trent Alexander-Arnold, Virgil van Dijk, and Alisson Becker: “They also need to sort out the three contracts… just to sort of increase that certainty going forward.” Ensuring these players remain committed to the club is crucial to maintaining Liverpool’s competitive edge.

Liverpool’s Depth: A Concern for Slot?

The issue of squad depth was a recurring theme in the podcast, with both Buckland and Winter questioning whether Liverpool did enough during the transfer window to bolster the team. Winter speculated, “Maybe Slot could have done with another couple of players,” while Marcus Buckland wondered aloud about the club’s pursuit of players like Anthony Gordon, now thriving at Newcastle.

The contrast between Liverpool’s bench and those of their Premier League rivals was also highlighted by Winter: “You look at the benches of the other teams at the top and it’s phenomenal.” Liverpool’s starting XI remains strong, but the lack of quality depth could be a stumbling block as the season progresses.

Winter and Buckland agreed that Liverpool’s failure to strengthen their squad could become an issue, particularly if injuries or poor form start to impact the team’s performance. Without reinforcements, Slot may struggle to rotate his players effectively in what promises to be a long and demanding season.

Can Slot Succeed at Liverpool?

Despite the setback, both Marcus Buckland and Henry Winter expressed cautious optimism about Slot’s tenure at Liverpool. “It’s a blip, but they’ll march on,” said Winter, suggesting that the defeat to Nottingham Forest, while concerning, is not indicative of deeper problems within the squad.

Slot is still early in his tenure at Liverpool, and as Winter pointed out, “It will take time to integrate his ideas.” However, time is not always on the side of Premier League managers, especially at a club like Liverpool, where expectations are high and success is demanded.

As the season continues, the next few games will be pivotal in determining Slot’s future at the club. Buckland concluded the podcast by stating, “Liverpool fans should stay calm; this is a new era, but there is plenty of potential.” The club’s ability to rebound from this defeat will be a true test of Slot’s leadership and vision for Liverpool’s future.