Papo na Colina
·1 September 2025
Controversial penalty angers Vasco, dubbed biggest blunder: ‘No contact’

In partnership with
Yahoo sportsPapo na Colina
·1 September 2025
The controversial penalty awarded against Vasco in the victory over Sport was harshly criticized by refereeing experts. Both PC Oliveira and Renata Ruel, two of the country's leading analysts, unanimously stated that referee Raphael Claus's decision was mistaken. The technical analysis, therefore, validates the strong complaints from Vasco players still on the field.
PC Oliveira, a commentator for Globo, was emphatic and classified the incident as the “mistake of the round.” He analyzed that the Sport forward sought contact with defender Lucas Freitas. Moreover, he criticized the lack of intervention by the video refereeing. The former referee stated:
“For me, what stands out is Matheus Alexandre, who touches the ball, bends his knee, and drags his foot, looking for contact. And falls. This is the incident that VAR should call.”
The commentator Renata Ruel, from ESPN, followed the same line of reasoning. For her, the contact in the incident was minimal and insufficient for awarding the penalty. The expert declared:
“In the penalty for Sport, I can't even see any touch. If there was, it's minimal. It's not enough to bring the player down.”
The opinion of the experts reinforces the feeling of injustice expressed by Lucas Freitas. The defender, who was outraged by the decision, gave a strong statement at halftime. He said:
“This harms not only my work but our team's. (…) I'm upset because this is my life, I'm not here playing around.”
Despite the error, Vasco managed to overcome the adversity and left the field with the victory.
+ Follow Papo na Colina's social media: Thread, Bluesky, Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, Youtube, Tiktok and Google News
This article was translated into English by Artificial Intelligence. You can read the original version in 🇧🇷 here.